If you're an American investor choosing between a condo in Miami, an apartment in Manhattan and a home in Dubai, the headline prices only tell part of the story. The bigger differences are in what you pay to buy, what you pay every year to hold, and how much rent the property brings in. Dubai charges a one-off 4% Dubai Land Department (DLD) fee and no annual property tax. Miami and New York charge less up front on many purchases, but then send a property tax bill every year.
This guide compares the three markets on prices, rental yields, transfer taxes and annual property taxes, for US citizens, green card holders and other US tax residents. It uses official sources first: the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, NYC's Department of Finance, the Florida Department of Revenue, the Miami-Dade Property Appraiser, the Dubai Land Department and DLD transaction data through DXBinteract. It is general information, not tax or legal advice.
Currency used in this guide: the UAE dirham is pegged at AED 3.6725 to USD 1, so AED 1 million is about USD 272,300. USD figures are rounded.

Credit: giggel, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0
Dubai vs Miami vs New York at a glance
| New York City | Miami-Dade County | Dubai | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Latest median sale price | USD 1.25 million for Manhattan co-ops and condos (Q3 2026) | USD 417,090 for condos and townhouses (September 2026) | From AED 1.885 million (USD 513,300) in Dubai Marina to AED 5.5 million (USD 1.5 million) on Palm Jumeirah for apartments (see table below) |
| Main purchase taxes | NY State transfer tax of 0.4% and NYC transfer tax of 1% or 1.425%, both legally the seller's unless the contract shifts them; buyer's "mansion tax" from 1% at USD 1 million and up | Documentary stamp tax on the deed of 60 cents per USD 100 (0.6%), plus a 45-cent surtax unless the deed transfers only a single-family dwelling | DLD registration fee of 4% of the price, listed as 2% buyer and 2% seller; the contract decides who pays |
| Annual property tax | Yes. Condos and co-ops are in Tax Class 2, taxed at about 12.44% of assessed value | Yes. In the City of Miami, about 19.95 mills (USD 19.95 per USD 1,000 of taxable value) | None. A municipal housing fee of 5% of annual rental value is paid by the tenant, or by the owner if no tenant |
| Currency risk for a US buyer | None, priced in US dollars | Low, the dirham is pegged to the dollar | |
Prices: what the latest data shows
New York. Manhattan's median sale price for co-ops and condos was USD 1.25 million in the third quarter of 2026, according to the Miller Samuel report for Douglas Elliman and Sotheby's International Realty's Q3 2026 Manhattan report. The two reports put the rise from a year earlier at 6% and 4% respectively.
Miami. MIAMI REALTORS data, produced by Florida Realtors from the local multiple listing services, shows a Miami-Dade median of USD 417,090 for condos and townhouses in September 2026, down 0.7% from USD 420,000 a year earlier. The single-family median was USD 692,000, up 4.1%. Condo supply stood at 12.3 months, which the association describes as a buyer's market.
Dubai. Dubai prices are quoted in dirhams but effectively move with the dollar because of the peg. Here are prime apartment areas often compared with Manhattan and Miami Beach:
| Area | Median apartment price | Price per sq ft (change, year on year) | Apartment sales (12 months) | Median annual rent | Gross rental yield |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dubai Marina | AED 1,885,000 (USD 513,300) | AED 1,990 / USD 542 (down 5.8%) | 2,164 | AED 108,000 (USD 29,400) | 7% |
| Business Bay | AED 2,000,000 (USD 544,600) | AED 2,430 / USD 662 (up 25%) | 5,824 | AED 92,000 (USD 25,100) | 7% |
| Jumeirah Beach Residence (JBR) | AED 2,650,000 (USD 721,600) | AED 1,680 / USD 457 (down 3.6%) | 476 | AED 135,000 (USD 36,800) | 9% |
| Downtown Dubai | AED 3,000,000 (USD 816,900) | AED 2,940 / USD 801 (down 1%) | 2,541 | AED 140,000 (USD 38,100) | 6% |
| Dubai Harbour | AED 4,550,000 (USD 1,238,900) | AED 3,770 / USD 1,027 (down 25.2%) | 591 | AED 170,000 (USD 46,300) | 6% |
| Palm Jumeirah | AED 5,500,000 (USD 1,497,600) | AED 3,380 / USD 920 (up 21.6%) | 1,094 | AED 185,000 (USD 50,400) | 6% |
Source: DXBinteract (Dubai Land Department transaction data), as of November 2026. USD at the peg of AED 3.6725 per USD. Gross yields are before service charges, vacancy and other costs. Price changes in smaller areas can swing with the mix of buildings sold.
So a Dubai Harbour or Palm Jumeirah apartment at the median costs about the same as the median Manhattan co-op or condo, while Dubai Marina and Business Bay sit closer to the Miami-Dade single-family median. For a longer view of price growth, see our analysis of Dubai's highest-appreciation communities from 2020 to 2025.

Credit: Superbass, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0
Rental yields
The DLD figures above show gross yields of 6% to 9% across Dubai's prime apartment areas, and areas further out can run higher. Our guide to Dubai rental yields by bedroom type breaks this down by unit size.
We don't quote a single yield for Manhattan or Miami here, because the published estimates we found used different methods and didn't agree closely enough. If you're comparing, work out a yield on a specific unit from its real rent, price, property tax and building fees. Remember that in Miami and New York the annual property tax comes straight off the rent, while a Dubai landlord with a tenant doesn't pay one.
Buying costs: transfer taxes vs the DLD fee
New York (State and City)
- NY State real estate transfer tax: USD 2 per USD 500 of price, which is 0.4%. The State says the seller pays it unless the contract says otherwise.
- NYC Real Property Transfer Tax: for a condo, co-op or one- to three-family house, 1% if the price is USD 500,000 or less and 1.425% above that.
- Mansion tax (paid by the buyer): 1% of the whole price on homes of USD 1 million or more. In NYC, a supplemental tax lifts the combined rate as the price rises: 1.25% from USD 2 million, 1.5% from USD 3 million, 2.25% from USD 5 million, 3.25% from USD 10 million, 3.5% from USD 15 million, 3.75% from USD 20 million and 3.9% from USD 25 million.
- Extra base tax: NYC residential sales of USD 3 million or more pay a further 0.25% State transfer tax.
Florida (Miami-Dade)
- Documentary stamp tax on the deed: in Miami-Dade, 60 cents per USD 100 of the price, against 70 cents in every other Florida county.
- Miami-Dade surtax: 45 cents per USD 100, which isn't due when the deed transfers only a single-family dwelling.
- Who pays: the Florida Department of Revenue says all parties are liable whoever agrees to pay, so the split is set in your contract.
- If you borrow: Florida also taxes the mortgage at 35 cents per USD 100 of the amount borrowed.
Dubai (DLD)
For a ready property, DLD lists a registration fee of 4% of the price, a trustee office fee of AED 4,000 (USD 1,089) plus VAT on sales of AED 500,000 or more, and small title deed, map, knowledge and innovation fees. The fee is the same for residents and non-residents, first and repeat buyers. Our guide to Dubai property taxes and fees covers the wider costs such as agency commission and service charges.
Worked example: a USD 1.25 million purchase
Here is the government tax on a cash purchase of USD 1,250,000 (AED 4,590,625), roughly the Manhattan median. Who pays each part depends on the contract, so the table shows the full charge and the usual payer.
| Market | Transfer taxes and fees | Total | Share of price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Manhattan condo (resale) | Mansion tax USD 12,500 (buyer); NY State transfer tax USD 5,000 and NYC transfer tax USD 17,812 (seller, unless the contract shifts them) | USD 35,312 | 2.8% (1% for the buyer if the seller pays the transfer taxes) |
| Miami-Dade | Deed stamp tax USD 7,500, plus surtax of USD 5,625 unless the deed transfers only a single-family dwelling | USD 7,500 to USD 13,125 | 0.6% to 1.05% |
| Dubai (ready property) | DLD fee AED 183,625 (USD 50,000); trustee fee AED 4,200 incl. VAT (USD 1,144); other DLD fees AED 520 (USD 142) | AED 188,345 (USD 51,286) | 4.1% (about half if the fee is split with the seller) |
On day one, then, Dubai usually costs the buyer more than Miami and, below the mansion tax brackets, more than New York. The picture changes once you hold the property for a few years.

Credit: B137, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0
Holding costs: annual property tax
Miami. Florida property tax is charged in mills, or dollars per USD 1,000 of taxable value. The Miami-Dade Property Appraiser's 2026 table lists a total of 19.9544 mills for the City of Miami (18.6681 in Miami Beach), and the City of Miami adopted its share unchanged in September 2026. On a taxable value of USD 1.25 million, 19.9544 mills is about USD 24,943 a year. Florida's homestead exemption is for owners whose permanent home it is, so an investor's condo doesn't get it. The Property Appraiser sets the taxable value, which can differ from your price.
New York. NYC taxes condos and co-ops in Tax Class 2. NYC's Department of Finance lists a Class 2 rate of about 12.44%, applied to an assessed value that Finance sets for each property. Your actual bill depends on that assessment, so ask for the unit's current tax bill before you buy.
Dubai. There is no annual property tax on owners. Dubai Municipality's housing fee is 5% of the annual rental value, paid by the tenant, or by the owner if there's no tenant. So a landlord with a tenant in place pays no recurring government tax on the property, only the building's service charges. Over five years, a Miami owner paying about USD 25,000 a year would pay around USD 125,000 in property tax, more than twice the Dubai buyer's one-off fees in the example above.
Taxes on rent and resale for US buyers
The UAE government says it doesn't levy income tax on individuals, and PwC's UAE tax summary notes there's no capital gains tax on individuals either. But US citizens and resident aliens are taxed on worldwide income, so Dubai rent and any gain on sale still go on your US return, as they would for a Miami or New York property. Because there's usually no UAE income tax to credit, the US tax is generally the only tax on that income. Our step-by-step guide for American buyers covers depreciation, FBAR and Form 8938 in more detail. Speak to a US CPA before you buy, especially if you plan to hold the property through a company or trust.
What this means for an American buyer
- Budget for Dubai's fee up front. At about 4%, it's usually the biggest government cost of the purchase, but it's paid once.
- Compare five-year costs, not day-one costs. Miami's and New York's annual property tax can overtake Dubai's one-off fee within a few years.
- Yields: DLD data shows 6% to 9% gross in prime Dubai apartment areas, before service charges and vacancy.
- Off-plan options spread Dubai payments over construction. See how off-plan payment plans work, and how off-plan premiums compare with resale prices.
- Choosing an area: our Business Bay area guide is a good start, and investors looking at the top end can read our Aman Residences Dubai guide. Buyers from Asia weighing the same question can read our Dubai vs Singapore comparison.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Dubai property cheaper than Miami or New York?
- It depends on the area. Manhattan's median co-op and condo price was USD 1.25 million in Q3 2026 and the Miami-Dade condo median was USD 417,090 in September 2026. DLD data shows median apartment prices from AED 1.885 million (USD 513,300) in Dubai Marina to AED 5.5 million (USD 1.5 million) on Palm Jumeirah.
Do you pay annual property tax on Dubai property?
- No. Dubai has no annual property tax on owners. Dubai Municipality's housing fee of 5% of annual rental value is paid by the tenant, or by the owner if there is no tenant. Miami and New York both charge annual property tax.
What does it cost to buy property in Dubai compared with New York and Miami?
- Dubai charges a DLD registration fee of 4% of the price plus small trustee and registration fees. On a USD 1.25 million purchase that is about USD 51,286 in total. In Manhattan the buyer's mansion tax is 1% from USD 1 million, with State and City transfer taxes of 0.4% and 1.425% usually paid by the seller. In Miami-Dade the deed stamp tax is 0.6%, plus a 0.45% surtax unless the deed transfers only a single-family dwelling.
What rental yields can American buyers expect in Dubai?
- DLD transaction data via DXBinteract shows gross yields of about 6% to 9% in prime Dubai apartment areas as of November 2026, including 7% in Dubai Marina and Business Bay, 9% in JBR and 6% in Downtown Dubai and Palm Jumeirah. Net returns are lower after service charges and vacancy.
Do Americans pay US tax on Dubai rental income?
- Generally yes. US citizens and resident aliens are taxed on worldwide income, so Dubai rent and gains go on the US return. The UAE does not levy income tax on individuals, so there is usually no foreign tax to credit. Confirm your position with a US CPA.
Related reading
- Buying Property in Dubai from the USA: A Step-by-Step 2026 Guide for American Buyers
- Understanding Dubai Property Taxes: The Ultimate 2025 Guide for Investors
- Dubai Rental Yield by Bedroom Type: Studios vs 1, 2 and 3-Beds in 12 Communities
- Dubai's Highest-Appreciating Communities and Projects, 2020–2025: Price and Rent Growth
- Dubai vs Singapore Property in 2026: Prices, Rental Yields and Stamp Duty (ABSD vs DLD Fees) Compared
Request details
Leave your details to download the details